In our Nice to Munich EV duel, the VW ID.4 Pro 2023 beats the Tesla Model S 2023 by 2 minutes, completing the 808km route in 8h 54min. Route calculated on September 4, 2026 using real-time charging station data.
Despite costing 48,299 less, the VW ID.4 Pro 2023 beats the Tesla Model S 2023 by 2 minutes on this route.
The Tesla Model S 2023's 505km range doesn't beat the VW ID.4 Pro 2023's 440km here - charging speed and efficiency matter more.
Winner
VW ID.4 Pro 2023
- Total time: 8h 54min (2 min faster)
- Charging stops: 3
- Charging time: 42min
- Energy: ~141 kWh
- Distance: 808km
Quick Comparison
| Metric |
Tesla Model S 2023 |
VW ID.4 Pro 2023 |
| Travel time |
8h 56min |
8h 54min |
| Charging time: |
37min |
42min |
| Charging stops: |
2 |
3 |
| Energy used |
~145 kWh |
~145 kWh |
Charging Strategy Breakdown
Tesla Model S 2023 Route
- Start: Nice (100% charge)
-
Stop 1:
Supercharger Swissminiatur (12 min, 19% → 47%)
-
Stop 2:
Supercharger Swiss Heidi Hotel (25 min, 10% → 64%)
- Arrival: Munich
VW ID.4 Pro 2023 Route
- Start: Nice (100% charge)
-
Stop 1:
Lario Est (18 min, 12% → 58%)
-
Stop 2:
GoFast McDonald's (14 min, 10% → 49%)
-
Stop 3:
Autohaus Seitz (10 min, 10% → 38%)
- Arrival: Munich
Why the VW ID.4 Pro 2023 Won
The VW ID.4 Pro 2023 achieved a 2-minute advantage over Tesla Model S 2023 on this 808km route. Key factors:
- Better efficiency: Lower energy consumption (~141 kWh vs ~152 kWh) means less time spent charging.
Related Comparisons